208 W 5th Street, Marshfield, WI info@marshfieldinsurance.net
About Us

A family business, serving you since 1984

For two generations, and counting, Marshfield Insurance has put service and customers first. Meet the people behind the agency.

Our history

In 1984, Roger Arnoldy became part owner of a firm with two other employees that focused mainly on life and health products. Roger brought a decade of property and casualty experience in commercial, home, and auto insurance.

In 1988, Roger and his wife, Yvonne, became sole owners, and the agency has grown steadily ever since. Leadership has since passed to Roger’s son, Nick Arnoldy.

We attribute that growth to a service and customer first focus, and we work to deliver strong insurance value and service through dedication and technology.

Marshfield Insurance Agency history
Since 1984Your local insurance company
45+“A-Rated” insurance companies represented
3Locations: Marshfield, Wisconsin Rapids, Neillsville
24+Licensed agents and staff ready to serve

The largest insurance office in the Marshfield area

With more than two dozen licensed agents, we serve clients across many U.S. states, with our main base in Central Wisconsin. Stop by, call, or email us for a free quote or consultation.

Roger Arnoldy, founder of Marshfield Insurance Agency

Our story, year by year

Four decades of growth, one family at the helm.

1984Roger Arnoldy becomes part owner of the firm.
1988Roger and Yvonne Arnoldy become sole owners.
1993The agency grows from half of a commercial building on Central Ave to the full building.
2001Adjacent property is acquired to make room for staff.
2003Sons Nick and Ryan Arnoldy join the agency.
2006The agency moves to larger space at 208 W. 5th St.
2016Nick Arnoldy continues the family business as second-generation leader.
2017Remodel at the current location.
2018Named Small Business of the Year by the Marshfield Chamber of Commerce.
2021Wisconsin Rapids location added.
2022Stratford Insurance acquired.
2023Neillsville location opens.

Why clients choose us

★

Family business

For two generations, and counting.

☺

Professional team

Educated agents ready to serve.

✓

Recognized leader

Named Small Business of the Year by the Marshfield Chamber of Commerce in 2018.

Marshfield Insurance team

Meet our team

Friendly, educated agents and staff, ready to help.

Nick Arnoldy

Nick Arnoldy, CIC, CPIA, CRM

Owner, Commercial Risk Agent

715-502-2272Email
Cory Hoffmann

Cory Hoffmann, CIC

Commercial Risk Agent

715-502-2270Email
Brian Varsho

Brian Varsho

Personal Risk Sales

715-502-4269Email
Ryan Horswill

Ryan Horswill

Claims Service

715-502-2275Email
Debbie Moore

Debbie Moore, CISR

Accounting

715-502-2903Email
Janilee

Janilee “Jana” Zvolena

Operations Manager

715-387-0055Email
Nicole Ottelien

Nicole Ottelien, CPIA

Sr. Commercial Service Agent

715-502-4902Email
Kassi Pagel

Kassi Pagel

Benefit Producer

715-387-6010Email
Tricia Trojan

Tricia Trojan

Personal Risk Agent (Neillsville)

715-502-2901Email
Kristi Canavan

Kristi Canavan, CISR

Commercial Lines Manager

715-502-2897Email
Cole Hoffmann

Cole Hoffmann

Commercial Risk Agent

715-387-6007Email
Adam Severt

Adam Severt

Commercial Service Agent

715-387-6017Email
Savannah Canavan

Savannah Canavan

Processor

715-387-6003Email
Nic Lotzer

Nic Lotzer

Commercial Risk Agent

715-387-6018Email
Lori Ellis

Lori Ellis

Processor

715-387-6021Email
Jaimie Bennett

Jaimie Bennett

Personal Service Agent (WI Rapids)

715-424-2800Email
McKenzie Meddaugh

McKenzie Meddaugh

Commercial Service Agent

715-449-8360Email
Bowden

Bowden “Bowdie” Krall

Personal Service Agent

715-502-2271Email
Kristina Holtzheimer

Kristina Holtzheimer

Commercial Service Agent

715-387-6035Email
Tabitha Green

Tabitha Green

Personal Service Agent

715-387-6041Email
Mary Zuelke

Mary Zuelke

Administrative Assistant

715-387-4443Email
Barb Larson

Barb Larson

Personal Service Agent

715-387-6008Email
Lacey Ladewig

Lacey Ladewig

Personal Service Agent (Neillsville)

715-387-6004Email

Insurance coverage cannot be bound or changed via submission of any online form or application. No binder, policy, change, addition, or deletion takes effect until a licensed agent confirms it directly.

Let’s talk

Stop by, call, or email us for a free quote or consultation.